Ecco le votazioni della rivista americana Game Informer
Winning Eleven 8 (Xbox/PS2, Konami): 8,75 / 8,75
Major League Baseball 2K5 (Xbox/PS2, Sega): 8,5 / 7,75
NBA Street V3 (Xbox/PS2/GC, EA): 9 / 8,75
Fight Night: Round 2 (Xbox/PS2/GC, EA): 9,25 / 9
MVP Baseball 2005 (Xbox/PS2/GC): 8,5 / 8,5
Gran Turismo 4 (PS2, Sony): 9,25 / 8,5
Devil May Cry 3 (PS2, Capcom): 9 / 9
Musashi: Samurai Legend (PS2, Square Enix): 8,25 / 7,5
Shining Tears (PS2, Sega): 7,75 / 7,25
Xenosaga Episode 2 (PS2, Namco): 7,75 / 7,5
Ys: The Ark of Napishtim (PS2, Konami): 7,5 / 7,25
Kessen 3 (PS2, Koei): 7,75 / 7,5
Nano Breaker (PS2, Konami): 5 / 5
Tenchu: Fatal Shadows (PS2, Sega): 7 / 6,75
Death by Degrees (PS2, Namco): 5,5 / 5,25